As I've mentioned before, whenever I complain about Cora not sleeping through the night or not napping well, my mom is quick to remind me that I NEVER slept as an infant or toddler, not for naps and not at night, until I was over 2-years-old. She says this to crush my hopes and dreams. I'm sure of it. Payback's a B, right? Then the other day she tells me about a study she read that said that 10% of babies are bad sleepers, and that those that are, usually don't start sleeping well until 2.5-3 years old. Then she said, "So, only 18 months to go!" And then she typed a little winking smiley face. Thanks mom.
(Don't worry, I'm just teasing her here, not being a defiant daughter.)
Anyway, it got me thinking. Is Cora really a bad sleeper?
And my answer is no. She is not. She is just a particular...
As a newborn, she slept well (for a newborn who was still nursing 3 times per night) and was basically asleep during the nighttime hours, even while nursing. (It still amazes me how well babies can eat in their sleep. And for that matter, how mama's can sleep through nursing sessions too. And for that matter, how much I still think about nursing. And how much I miss it.) At 3-months-old, she started sleeping through the night (10+ hours, coinciding with the introduction of the
Miracle Blanket, and hence the reason I now recommend that thing to all new parents), and it lasted an entire month. Just long enough to fool us into thinking Cora was beating her brother's record (since he didn't start STTN until 4-months-old, though he never regressed after that milestone, unlike SOME babies...)

Then she had a delayed growth spurt (perhaps because she was born a few weeks early?) and went back to eating once or twice per night. At 5-months-old we weaned her of the swaddle (not because we wanted to give up the Miracle, but because we were worried about her turning over in her sleep and getting stuck, since she'd started rolling), and her sleep patterns started to get rocky. By 6-months-old she was no longer sleeping by herself in her crib for longer than an hour or two at a time, and by 7-months-old she refused to be put in her crib at all. That's when we introduced the pacifier (because she had started using ME as pacifier) and moved her into our bed full-time. It was the only way any of us got to sleep in stretches long enough to hit good REM cycles. And you know what? Even though she then continued to nurse once per night until she was 11-months-old (hard to pass up a snack when you're sleeping snuggled up next to it all night long), she also slept through the night most nights (eating in her sleep and not really waking either of us).

She became a "bad" sleeper again when we decided to try and move her back to her crib for the start of the night (because this mama had chores to do in the evenings that couldn't be done with our light sleeper snoozing at the top of the stairs, where everything echos, and daddy needed to study). After a lot of effort on our part, we finally convinced her to sleep from 8:00pm-1:00am/3:00am in her crib, in her new room (downstairs, and with a new white noise player, an iPod speaker system that allowed us to loop RockabyeBaby music all night long). When she woke, we'd take turns going down and sleeping with her in the guest bed for the remainder of the night (so that ever other night, we each got a full night of sleep in our own bed - score!). And if she was having a bad night (teething or sick) and woke up before we went to bed ourselves, we'd just sleep all night with her. And on those nights, she'd then sleep the rest of the night through, without wake-ups, comfortable and safe with mama or daddy by her side. Sure, there were nights when she'd be up for hours for no reason, but those were actually pretty few and far between.

And then there's the most recent development, with her sleeping in her crib in James' room. Sleeping through the night consistently (until we messed up her schedule with vacation, at least). Occasionally she even naps in his bed with him, or ends up there in the middle of the night (only very recently) when mama and daddy don't want to sleep in the guest bed (because we're still awake doing other things). The kids really like sharing a room, and they are so young still that it doesn't matter. Anything that gets us all more sleep is what we roll with. We are unwilling to let our daughter cry (or scream like a banshee, as is more apt). She wakes James, she stresses our nerves, and she quickly works herself into a frenzy that then has her awake and upset for hours. So our pediatrician can save her CIO advice for some other family, 'cause the Lindsay's aren't listening!

So basically, what it boils down to, is as long as she's not alone, she sleeps. Just because she doesn't want to sleep by herself in her own room does not make her a bad sleeper. She's always been a baby that thrives on skin-to-skin contact (she will literally push your sleeve aside or lift your shirt to lay her cheek on your upper arm or belly while snuggling), so we've simply accepted the fact that Cora is a clingy, lovey-dovey, physical-touch-needing child, and as long as we give her what she wants (NEEDS!), then she is happy. And thus we are happy.
And maybe in another year or so Miss Independent (in respects other than sleeping) will decide that sleeping alone in her room is cool...
But we're not holding our breath!